DIY Pet Toys: Fun and Easy Ideas for Cats and Dogs

By the Popick Team | Published: January 25, 2026

A dog playing with a homemade rope toy

Keeping your pet mentally stimulated and physically active is crucial for their well-being. While store-bought toys are great, you can create fantastic, engaging toys using simple items you probably already have at home. Here are some safe and easy DIY ideas for both cats and dogs.

Safety First! Always supervise your pet with homemade toys. Use durable, non-toxic materials. Discard any toy that starts to break apart to avoid choking hazards.

For Cats:

1. The Classic Cardboard Box Fort

Never underestimate the power of a cardboard box. Cut out various-sized holes in one or more boxes, connect them to create tunnels, and hide a few treats or a pinch of catnip inside. It’s a castle, a hiding spot, and a puzzle all in one.

2. Toilet Paper Roll Puzzle Feeder

Don't throw away those empty toilet paper rolls! Fold one end of the roll inward to close it off. Drop a few treats inside. Then, fold the other end to seal it. Your cat will have a blast batting it around to get the treats out.

3. Fabric Wand Toy

Find a sturdy stick or a wooden dowel. Tightly tie several strips of durable fabric (like fleece or old t-shirts) to one end. You can add a jingle bell to the inside of the fabric knot for extra fun. Wave it around and watch your cat's hunting instincts kick in.

For Dogs:

1. The Muffin Tin Puzzle

This is a fantastic brain game for dogs. Place a few treats or pieces of kibble in some of the cups of a muffin tin. Cover all the cups with tennis balls or other dog-safe toys. Your dog will have to use their nose and problem-solving skills to figure out where the treats are.

2. The "Snuffle" Box

Take a cardboard box and fill it with dog-safe packing paper, old t-shirts, or towels. Sprinkle your dog's kibble or small treats inside. Your dog will have to use its powerful sense of smell to forage for its food, which is a highly rewarding and calming activity.

3. Knotted T-Shirt Tug Toy

Take two old, clean t-shirts. Cut them into several long, 3-4 inch wide strips. Hold all the strips together, tie a strong knot in the middle, and then braid the two sides. Tie a final knot at each end. You now have a durable, washable tug-of-war toy that is softer on your dog's mouth than rope.

DIY toys are a wonderful way to recycle household materials, save money, and provide your pet with personalized enrichment.